Electrical Troubleshooting Quiz, Sept. 11, 2012

A critical production line has had recurring problems with downtime

 

Electrical Troubleshooting Quiz

A critical production line has had recurring problems with downtime. The symptoms have included such things as transformer loss, seemingly random breaker trips, failure of electronic components, and the loss of several small servo motors. The response thus far has been to replace the failed components.

The plant manager suspects a root cause and has specifically requested you as the person to find it. The repair records show frequent downtime going back to about seven months ago, and then there aren’t any failures until four more years back. What should you look at next, and what are some likely issues?

Naturally, you want to use your power analyzer to look at the power quality. It won't be surprising if your analyzer shows high harmonics and/or distorted waveforms. It would be surprising if the failures aren’t due to power quality problems traceable to an error in that repair of seven months ago.

How can you find that error? Start by opening the disconnects to all the equipment on this line. If the power quality anomalies disappear, then the source of the PQ problems is in the equipment. Next:

  • Visually inspect for bonding errors and load side grounding; fix as needed to comply with Article 250 Part V.
  • If that repair involved a motor or drive replacement, a motor/drive mismatch is likely; contact the drive manufacturer.
  • If power factor correction capacitors are present, recalculate the size needed. Note that motor drives and PF capacitors typically are incompatible; get a PF-corrected drive.

Discuss this Article 1

Jim H (not verified)
on Sep 11, 2012

The proceedure above may not eliminate the PQ problem because we often leave the lights on. A failing ballast sometimes shorts a few windings together and that may have intermittant connection. Kettering action will induce large but low power spikes on the lighting circuit. If it is 277volt lighting and there is no 1:1 isolation transformer, that spike has direct access to all other 480/277v equipment including drives, and motors. The 120vac controls are probably resonably protected by relatively high impedance of control power transformers but an improper ground bond can allow high neutral spikes.
This is just a paraphrase of what I believe was an EC&M article of several years ago that made an impression on me.

Post new comment
Sign In or register to use your Electrical Construction & Maintenance (EC&M) Magazine ID
(optional)

White Papers
EC&M Learning Center
Webinars
EC&M TV
Apr. 15, 2013
video

The Westex Difference

Learn what sets Westex apart from other flame resistant fabric manufacturers....More

Newsletter Signup

Connect With Us