Electrical Troubleshooting Quiz, July 10, 2012

After the first motor replacement, problems, such as inexplicable motor overload blowouts, started occurring.

The two large compressors for plant air are housed in a small cinder block structure tacked onto the main building. The motors have each been replaced twice in the past five years. After the first replacement, problems, such as inexplicable motor overload blowouts, started occurring. Those led to the second replacements, which solved nothing. And the motors run hot.

There's been some conjecture that the cinder block housing is insufficient, resulting in condensation in the windings. However, you've noted the housing isn't what has changed and is probably not the source of the problem. What troubleshooting steps should you take next?

You should strongly suspect motor installation errors. One common problem is the misuse of solderless connectors. These connectors are designed to grab and mechanically connect the wires as you twist the connector on. If you twist the wires together first, the mechanical connection is poor; it's likely to become a high-impedance connection.

The poor connections resulting from this misuse usually exhibit different impedances, which means voltage imbalance on the motor. That would explain the "run hot" part.

  • Disassemble the connections.
  • Conduct insulation resistance testing and AC resistance testing on the branch circuit wiring.
  • Before reconnecting the motor, clean the wires with copper cleaning compound.
  • Check the entire installation for bonding errors. This is load side equipment, so nothing should be "grounded" (see Art. 100 definition).

To determine where to look next, conduct vibration analysis and power quality analysis while the compressor's in the loading phase.

Discuss this Article 6

jason whaley (not verified)
on Jul 10, 2012

I dont know the ventilation that exist , but if there is not proper ventilation to this block room , THAT IS A SEVERE PROBLEM !! If it is a small building, you are gonna need some serious CFM.S

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 11, 2012

electrical code calls for you to twist wires to be mechanically attached before using connector.......

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 24, 2012

The NEC absolutely does not require twisting of conductors before installation of the wire connector. The NEC only states you must use the connectors in compliance with the manufactures directions. Some manufacturers may recommend twisting. I personally have never used a wire connector that had instructions recommending twisting of the conductors before installation. Most wire connectors instructions state "twisting not required" leaving it open to each individual to choose how they prefer to install the product. There are pros and cons of both installation methods but ultimately if you make a good connection I don't care which method a person chooses.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Apr 9, 2013

Give us chapter and verse, if you believe that.

rick r. (not verified)
on Jul 11, 2012

-perform amp check each lead for draw.
-check bearings for wear, proper maintenance if required.(grease).
-check for proper ventilation in the cinder block house.(could overheat due to lack of ventilation.
-Check belt(if applicable)
-Check connections( internal)
-Make sure dirt is not getting into the motor.
-Is this oil cooled, air cooled, unit???
-Check shaft for alignment.
-Check for harmonics, eddy currents, hot grounds.
-Did any lightning stricke occur ??????

John T (not verified)
on Jul 16, 2012

The ventalation did not change, pwoer side wiring did not change.
so either it there is a poor connection { maybe in the starter, cause of the original failure} or poor alignment of the motor causing high running load.

Post new comment
Sign In or register to use your Electrical Construction & Maintenance (EC&M) Magazine ID
(optional)

White Papers
EC&M Learning Center
Webinars
EC&M TV
Apr. 15, 2013
video

The Westex Difference

Learn what sets Westex apart from other flame resistant fabric manufacturers....More

Newsletter Signup

Connect With Us