Lighting Controls for Intelligent Buildings

What is in this article?:

Why total light management holds the greatest opportunity for energy savings in commercial buildings

Sidebar 3: Electronic Circuitry Adds Efficiency

An electronic linear fluorescent dimming ballast changes the 60 cycle waveform from the power source into a high frequency AC waveform while also regulating the current flow. Constant current pulse width modulation is used for the dimming function, which is expressed as a factor (percentage) of relative lamp output, or power. The dimming range extends from full output (100%) to the lowest level, typically 1%.  Full output, in turn, is based on the ballast factor (e.g. 0.88, 1.00 or 1.18). Generally, the change in light output — either raising or lowering — is not noticeable to the occupants. Interestingly, when fluorescent lamps are dimmed, the human eye may perceive a higher light level than is actually being produced, because of adaptation.

Discuss this Article 1

dclasen
on Apr 18, 2013

DALI is the only recognized open standard mentioned I can see from this article.

Why is it lumped in some nefarious category "Two-wire, low-voltage digital control for fluorescent dimming (DALI specifications or similar designs)." ? Please let me know what other free topology two wire open protocol systems are out there to compare?

Compared to (three wire) EIA-485 based proprietary or open (article leaves undefined) DALI is a free topology system and is significantly better than 0-10v. It shouldn't even be compared with 0-10v systems because the only comparison is that both provide dimming. Additionally, the free topology and powered multi-sensors make it a superior installation to EIA-485 and 0-10v systems by far. No contest.

"A number of lighting equipment manufacturers offer a digital dimming system with the same general capabilities as a DALI system; however, they may use their own communication protocols and associated hardware to deliver a complete lighting system. " --- A serious understatement. These other "similar" systems deliver the goal with locked down single vendor solutions. Therefore, not really close to the "same general capabilities" because there is no ability for an open procurement and design of your lighting system.

US HVAC systems seem years ahead of lighting control systems delivered in the US market in regards to use of open protocols. The US is even years behind the world adopting DALI.

What I'd like to see is better comparisons made because equating something like DALI to proprietary and 0-10v systems at the same level is maddening.

Post new comment
Sign In or register to use your Electrical Construction & Maintenance (EC&M) Magazine ID
(optional)

White Papers
EC&M Learning Center
Webinars
EC&M TV
Sep. 14, 2012
Video
Electrical Construction and Maintenance

Arlington: Non-Metallic Floor Boxes

Arlington's Non-Metallic Floor Boxes give installers the fast and easy way to put a receptacle in the floor. Available for new concrete pours, installed floors, and adjustable boxes for all other new floor installations....More

Newsletter Signup

Connect With Us