Reduced-Voltage Autotransformer Starter Performance Misunderstood

Find more articles on: Transformers

The author of the article “Reduced-Voltage Starters: Choosing The Best Type For Your Application” (June 1998 issue) made an error with the following excerpt, which begins on page 52: “For example, we were pretty certain the 2000-hp motors would not start on 150% of full-load current, which would be the 50% tap on an autotransformer starter. We did expect them to start on 384% of full-load current, which would be the 80% tap on an autotransformer starter. However, we didn’t know if they would start at 254% of full-load current, which would be the 65% tap.”

I wish to present a training approach that usually prevents the confusion associated with the performance of autotransformer starters.

While starting an AC induction motor at reduced voltage, the line current and motor current may or may not be the same, depending on the type of reduced voltage starter used. In a primary-impedance starter and solid-state starter, the line current and the motor current are the same because the resistors, reactors, or SCRs are inserted in series with the line and motor. The current in a series circuit is the same at any point in the circuit.

However, in an autotransformer starter, the line current and motor current are not the same. Using a motor with a 600% inrush current and connecting to the 50% voltage tap of the autotransformer, the motor current will be 300% (50% of 600%), but the line current will be only 150% (25% of 600%). No other type of reduced-voltage starter can supply, for example, the torque of a 300% current start while drawing only 150% current from the line.

Perhaps the excerpt should read: “For example, we were pretty certain the 2000-hp motors would not start on 300% of full-load motor current (150% line current), which would be the 50% tap on an autotransformer starter. We did expect them to start on 480% of full-load motor current (384% line current), which would be the 80% tap on an autotransformer starter. However, we didn’t know if they would start at 390% of full-load motor current (254% line current), which would be the 65% tap.”

The article also states a 300% motor current start was satisfactory with the solid-state starter (and 310% or 290%). I agree. If a 300% motor current start was satisfactory with the solid-state starter, then a solid-state starter is not necessary. In this case, an autotransformer starter connector on the 50% voltage tap provides a 300% motor current start while drawing only 150% line current—outperforming the solid-state starter.

All these percentages mentioned assume an ideal transformer. In the field, the values are slightly different, due to losses (including the required magnetizing current in the autotransformer). For proper selection and application of reduced-voltage starters, you should consider both motor current and line current starting.

Mac McMillin, P.E.
Senior Application Engineer
Square D Co.
Seneca, S.C.


Want to use this article? Click here for options!





Acceptable Use Policy
blog comments powered by Disqus

what's wrong here?

What's Wrong Here?

May 10, 2012 12:44 PM

What's Wrong Here?

Apr 19, 2012 10:09 AM

What's Wrong Here?

Apr 5, 2012 2:27 PM

View all What's Wrong Here?

product spotlight

EV charger tester

May 25, 2012 8:26 AM

EV charger tester

The Electrician is portable tester that verifies critical power and safety requirements of electric vehicle (EV) chargers...

View all 2012 Product Spotlights

Free Product Info

Our Product Information site is the ultimate online resource for products and services offered by Advertisers featured in our Magazine. This service is provided as a quick and easy way to request Product Information online. Get FREE product information now.

Recent Comments

More...


Social Media

More ways to stay informed...

follow us on twitter

Find us on Facebook

EC&M Whitepaper

Arc Mitigation –A Three-Step Approach

Did you know that an arc-flash incident hospitalizes 5-7 workers per day in North America, severely impacting processes and profitability with lost production? Download This Sponsored Whitepaper Today!

What's New in Residential Cabling?
Date: Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Time: 2:00pm ET


In this The Home Depot sponsored Low Voltage Webinar, Ron Kipper RCDD / NTS will discuss the need for compression style coaxial connectors and the migration of the entire CATV, Satellite and Audio / Video industry to them. Register Today!

Grounding Versus Bonding
Now Available On-Demand


In this 60-minute FREE webinar, Mike Holt of Mike Holt Enterprises, Inc. will explain the purpose of grounding and bonding as related to the most current requirements set forth in the 2011 NEC. Register to View On-Demand!

resources

product info icon

product info

tradeshow icon

tradeshow

research icon

research

industry links

industry links

rss icon

rss

Browse Back Issues

Browse Back Issues